Skip to Main Content
Carmella's Plates and Pints logo topCarmella's Plates and Pints logo scroll
  • (412)-918-1215
  • carmellas1908@gmail.com
  • 1908 East Carson Street , Pittsburgh
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Order
  • Music & Events
  • Daily Features
  • Parties
  • Passport Books
  • Gift Cards
  • Jobs
  • Twitter pageFacebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
Carmella's Plates and Pints logo topCarmella's Plates and Pints logo scroll
  • Twitter pageFacebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Order
  • Music & Events
  • Daily Features
  • Parties
  • Passport Books
  • Gift Cards
  • Jobs
  • MENU

Our Menu

Dinner MenuDesserts & NightcapsSunday BrunchMother's Day Sunday Brunch & Dinner

Share Plates

Herb Confit Potato Wedges (GF) (V)

$6.00
Calabrian Aioli

Fresh Baguette Plate (GF*) (V)

$5.00
Pesto Herb Oil : ADD Olive Tapenade +3

Heirloom Tomato Salad (GF) (V*)

$12.00
Fresh Marinated Mozzarella / Basil / Bacon Chutney / Balsamic Reduction

Marinated Olives (GF) (V)

$12.00
Castelvetrano Olives / Citrus Infused Olive Oil

Elote Pierogi (V)

$13.00
Potato & Cotija Cheese / Roasted Corn Salsa / Chipotle Sour Cream

Ricotta Toast (GF*) (V)

$13.00
Toasted Farm Bread / Whipped Ricotta / Roasted Garlic & Tomato Tapenade / Oregano

Melon Salad (GF) (V)

$13.00
Watermelon / Honeydew / Cantaloupe / Fresh Mozzarella / Citrus Mint Vinaigrette

Nashville Shrimp Skewers (GF)

$14.00
Corn Battered Shrimp / Cool Cucumber Sauce

Wagyu Meatballs

$15.00
Smoked Provolone / Toasted Baguette

Caesar Salad (GF*, V)

$12.00
Romaine / House Caesar / Shaved Parmesan / Toasted Breadcrumbs / Crispy Capers : Salmon +15 | Shrimp +10 | Chicken +8

Cheese Board (GF*) (V)

$24.00
{Chef’s Selection of Cheeses} Candied Nuts / Fresh Fruit / Candied Fruit / Fresh Baguette / Olives : ADD Cured Meats +$12

Antipasto Salad (GF) (V*)

$22.00
Romaine / Heirloom Tomato / Shallots / Cucumber / Rosemary Ham / Coppa / Soppressata / Olive Mix / Provolone / Creamy Italian Dressing

Kitchen Gratitude

$5.00
Show some love to our awesome culinary team! (*Please advise your server prior to requesting your check)

Dinner Plates

Heirloom Tomato & Pesto Risotto (GF) (V)

$23.00
Sun-dried Tomatoes / Garlic Confit / Parmigiano Reggiano : ADD Salmon +15 / Shrimp +10 / Chicken +8 {Pair with: Cielo Dal 1908 - Delle Venezie DOC 2022 Pinot Grigio, Veneto, Italy ... 49}

Braised Chicken (GF)

$25.00
Coconut Rice / Avocado / Mango Salsa / Crispy Plantains {Pair with: J M Fonseca Twin Vines 2022 Vinho Verde, Portugal ... 49}

Cacio e Pepe (V)

$22.00
Kitchen Crafted Chitarra Pasta / Pecorino Romano / Toasted Black Peppercorn / Garlic Bread. : ADD Salmon +15 / Shrimp +10 / Chicken +8 {Pair with: Frank Family Vineyards 2020 Carneros Chardonnay, Napa Valley, CA ... 89}

Bison Meatloaf (GF*)

$29.00
Buttermilk Mashed Potatoes / Summer Vegetables / Mushroom & Herb Gravy / Grilled Farm Bread {Pair with: Collina San Ponzio Barolo DOCG 2020 Nebbiolo, Piedmont, Italy ... 79}

Wagyu Bolognese

$27.00
Kitchen Crafted Torchio Pasta / Parmigiano Reggiano / Garlic Bread. {Pair with: Napa Cut 2022 Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley, CA ... 69}

Steak Frites* (GF*)

$39.00
Truffle Oil Fries / Summer Vegetables / House Steak Sauce. {Pair with: Orin Swift Cellars - Mercury Head 2021 Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley, CA ... 299}

Blackened Catfish (GF*)

$25.00
Beans & Greens / Chili Gastrique / Cornbread {Pair with: Cakebread Cellars 2021 Chardonnay, Napa Valley, CA ... 89}

Seared Tuna (GF)

$28.00
Sesame Crusted / Summer Vegetables / Jasmine Rice / Avocado Purée / Tropical Salsa. {Pair with: Groth 2020 Sauvignon Blanc, Napa Valley, CA ... 79}

Tuscan Pasta (V)

$24.00
Kitchen Crafted Radiatore / Sun-dried Tomatoes / Garlic Confit / Parmigiano Reggiano / Garlic Bread : ADD Salmon +15 / Shrimp +10 / Chicken +8 {Pair with: Basilica Cafaggio 2022 Chianti Classico, Tuscany, Italy ... 59}

Wagyu Burger* (GF*)

$19.00
Sharp Cheddar / Burgundy Onions / Steak Sauce Aioli / Roasted Tomato Dill Pickles / Herb Confit Potato Wedges : ADD Peppered Bacon +4 {Pair with: Giovanni Chiappini - ‘Ferruggini’ Bolgheri 2022 ‘Rosso’ Super Tuscan, Tuscany, Italy ... 69}

Kids Plates

For guests 10 years old and younger

Spaghetti & Meatballs

$15.00

Chicken Fingers & Fries (GF)

$15.00

Grilled Cheese & Fries (V)

$15.00

YOUR DINING EXPERIENCE

DIETARY NEEDS

Please advise your server prior to requesting your check before placing your order, inform your server of any special preparation or food allergies. We are unable to guarantee that any menu listed can be completely free of allergens

COOKED TO TEMP

(*) These items are cooked to order. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

CAKEAGE FEE

$3.00
per person

CORKAGE FEE

$15.00
per bottle

GF | V

Gluten Free | Vegetarian

Breads locally sourced by MEDITERRA BAKE HOUSE

*Gluten free bread available upon request

Desserts

* All desserts made in house *

Brûlée of the Day

$12.00

Skillet Cookie

$12.00
Chocolate Chip / Vanilla Ice Cream

Pineapple Upside Down Cake

$12.00
Butter Rum

Espresso Martini

$13.00
Espresso Infused Vodka Dark Creme de Cacao / Espresso Liquor

Spiked Cinnamon Bun Iced Coffee*

$10.00
Tullamore D.E.W., Irish Whipped Cream, Caramel *Available as mocktail, ask server

Kitchen Gratitude

$5.00
Show some love to our awesome culinary team! *Please advice your server prior to requesting your check

Nightcaps

* 160 Scotches featured in wooden book *

INFUSED LIMONCELLO VODKA

$8.00

BANANA OLD-FASHIONED

$10.00
BANANA BOURBON, Chocolate Bitter, Brown Sugar

BLUEBERRY OLD-FASHIONED

$10.00
BLUEBERRY BOURBON, Lemon Bitter, Basil Simple

PEACH OLD-FASHIONED

$10.00
PEACH BOURBON, Angostura, Peach Bitter, Clove, Brown Sugar

IRISH COFFEE

$10.00
Tullamore D.E.W. Irish Whiskey, Irish Whipped Cream, Chocolate Shavings

HOT TODDY

$10.00
1) BANANA BOURBON | 2) BLUEBERRY BOURBON | 3) PEACH BOURBON {select one} • Lemon, Honey Ginger Syrup, Cinnamon

Grand Marnier

$9.00
Premium blend of cognacs with wild tropical oranges from the Caribbean.

Grand Marnier Cuvée 1880

$49.00
A distinctive liqueur made exclusively of premium Grande Champagne cognac XO in combination with tropical orange liqueur.

Martell Cordon Bleu

$19.00
An explosion of spicy fruit notes and elegant richness.

Rémy Martin VSOP

$15.00
Well-balanced and multi-layered cognac with notes of vanilla, stone fruit and licorice.

Lustau - East India Solar Cream Sherry, Spain

$7.00
Vibrant notes of maple syrup, brown sugar, shoe polish, raisin, all very well integrated. On the palate it is smooth and rich at the beginning, full of prune and burned oranges peel flavors.

Terra d'Oro Zinfandel Port, CA

$7.00
Rich flavors of cocoa, toffee, raisin, and coffee that follow through to a full-bodied, medium-sweet palate with a long finish

Felsina Vin Santo del Chianti Classico 2009

$19.00
Peach, apricot, pineapple and tropical dried fruit aromas. Consistency on the palate, softness and elegance nicely structured by the oak barrels. Wine with great balance, favorable acidity and a well-harmonized residual sugar. Long in the mouth.

FRENCH PRESS COFFEES & TEAS

(2 CUP) Columbino ~ Local PGH Roaster

DOUBLE SHOT ESPRESSO - All Day DARK ROAST (Honduras)

$6.00
Commonplace Coffee: Dark roast. Notes of baking chocolate, toasted marshmallows, molasses

Commonplace Coffee - Yuki Minami (Brazil)

$6.00
Medium roast. Notes of milk chocolate, nectarine, candied nuts Medium roast. Notes of milk chocolate, nectarine, candied nuts

Commonplace Coffee - All Day DARK ROAST (Honduras)

$6.00
Dark roast. Notes of baking chocolate, toasted marshmallows, molasses

Commonplace Coffee - Popayan DECAF

$6.00
Decaf. Notes of milk chocolate, caramel, dried apricot

English Breakfast Black Tea

$6.00

"Life is short, eat dessert first."

Sunday Brunch Plates

SUNDAY 11:00 am – 3:00 pm
Acoustic Music 3:00 – 6:00 pm

Omelette du Jour (GF*) (V)

$15.00
Breakfast Hash ... ADD Peppered Bacon +4 | Sausage +3

Ham & Cheese (GF*)

$17.00
Imported Italian Rosemary Ham, Gruyère Cheese, Dijonnaise, Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion, Grilled Farm Bread, Breakfast Hash

Bourbon Banana Bake (V)

$16.00
Brown Sugar - Bourbon Caramel Glaze, Buttery Brioche

Breakfast Sandwich (GF*) (V*)

$17.00
English Muffin, Peppered Bacon, Sausage, Fried Egg, Sharp Cheddar, Truffle Aioli, Lettuce, Tomato, Breakfast Hash

Wagyu Burger* (GF*)

$19.00
Sharp Cheddar, Burgundy Onions, Roasted Tomato, Steak Sauce Aioli, Dill Pickles, Breakfast Hash | +ADD Peppered Bacon +4

Carmella's Breakfast (GF*)

$17.00
Soft Scrambled Eggs, Waffle, House-Made Sausage, Peppered Bacon, Fresh Fruit, Toast & Jam, Breakfast Hash

Berry Corn Fritters (V)

$16.00
Seasonal Berries, Sorghum-Glaze

Grilled Chicken Sandwich (GF*)

$17.00
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Duke’s Mayo, Grilled Farm Bread, Breakfast Hash

Smoked Salmon Toast (GF*)

$16.00
Grilled Farm Bread, Smoked Salmon, Crispy Capers, Pickled Shallots, Dill Cream Cheese, Breakfast Hash

Steak Scramble Bowl* (GF*)

$19.00
Marinated Flank Steak, Scrambled Eggs, Sharp Cheddar, House Steak Sauce, Breakfast Hash | +ADD Peppered Bacon +4

Kitchen Gratitude

$5.00
Show some love to our awesome culinary team! (*Please advise your server prior to requesting your check)

Breads locally sourced by MEDITERRA BAKE HOUSE

*Gluten free bread available upon request

Sunday Brunch Drinks

$20 Mimosa Madness! 1/2 PRICE carafes, bubbly brunch feature (11 AM - 1 PM ONLY)

MIMOSA

$10.00
Prosecco, Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice | [Carafe --- 40]

MANMOSA

$10.00
Pilsner, Ketel Oranje, Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice

BLOODY MARY

$10.00
INFUSED BLOODY MARY VODKA, House-Made Tomato Juice, Lemon, Jalapeño Bacon, Pickle

ESPRESSO MARTINI

$13.00
Espresso Infused Vodka / Dark Crème de Cacao / Espresso Liquor

BANANA OLD-FASHIONED

$10.00
BANANA BOURBON, Chocolate Bitter, Brown Sugar

IRISH COFFEE

$10.00
Paddy's Irish Whiskey, Irish Whipped Cream, Chocolate Shavings

HOT TODDY

$10.00
1) BANANA BOURBON | 2) BLUEBERRY BOURBON | 3) PEACH BOURBON {select one} • Honey Ginger Syrup, Lemon, Cinnamon

FRESH SQUEEZED OJ

$5.00

PUMPKIN SPICE ICED COFFEE*

$7.00
Irish Whipped Cream, Caramel (non-alcoholic) *ADD Paddy's Irish Whiskey for $4 uncharge

DOUBLE SHOT ESPRESSO - All Day Dark Roast (Honduras)

$6.00
Baking chocolate, toasted marshmallow, molasses

IT’S THE GREAT PUMPKIN WAYNE BROWN

$12.00
Baked Pumpkin Bourbon, Brown Sugar, Angostura, Cinnamon Bitter

FRENCH PRESS COFFEES & TEAS

(2 CUP) Columbino ~ Local PGH Roaster

DOUBLE SHOT ESPRESSO - All Day DARK ROAST (Honduras)

$6.00
Commonplace Coffee: Dark roast. Notes of baking chocolate, toasted marshmallows, molasses

Commonplace Coffee - Yuki Minami (Brazil)

$6.00
Medium roast. Notes of milk chocolate, nectarine, candied nuts

Commonplace Coffee - All Day DARK ROAST (Honduras)

$6.00
Dark roast. Notes of baking chocolate, toasted marshmallows, molasses

Commonplace Coffee - Papayan DECAF (Columbia)

$6.00
Decaf. Notes of milk chocolate, caramel, dried apricot

English Breakfast Black Tea

$6.00

Sides

Two Eggs

$5.00

Peppered Bacon

$4.00

House-made Sausage

$3.00

Toast & Jam

$3.00

Waffle

$4.00

STARTER PLATES

No Substitutions * No modifications * Gratuity Not Included

MUFFIN FLIGHT TRIO

$10.00
Strawberry, Blueberry, Chocolate Chip

WAGYU MEATBALLS

$15.00
Smoked Provolone, Toasted Baguette

RED PEPPER HUMMUS (GF*) (V)

$10.00
Toasted Baguette, Cucumbers / Carrots / Olive Oil

CHOPPED SIDE SALAD (GF) (V)

$6.00
Romaine, Cucumber, Tomato, Olives, Red Onion Vinaigrette

FRESH BAGUETTE PLATE (GF*) (V)

$5.00
Pesto Herb Oil

MAIN PLATES

No Substitutions * No modifications * Gratuity Not Included

CARMELLA’S STEAK BREAKFAST

$28.00
Top Sirloin Steak, Soft Scrambled Eggs, Waffle, Peppered Bacon, Breakfast Hash, Fresh Fruit, Toast & Jam (UNTIL 3PM)

WAGYU BURGER*

$23.00
Peppered Bacon, Sharp Cheddar, Burgundy Onions, Roasted Tomato, Steak Sauce Aioli, Dill Pickles, Fresh Cut Confit Fries

CORN CRUSTED TROUT

$33.00
White Cheddar Grits, Black-Eyed Peas Chili Pepper Gastrique

SEAFOOD LINGUINE

$33.00
Kitchen Crafted Pasta, Shrimp, Bay Scallops, Zucchini, Spinach, Onions, Cherry Tomatoes

BRAISED LAMB SHANK (GF)

$36.00
Creamy Polenta, Roasted Asparagus, Lamb Jus, House Mint Jelly

CHICKEN & BISCUITS

$25.00
Seasoned Fried Chicken, Buttermilk Biscuit, Braised Greens, Calabrian Sausage Gravy

BISON MEATLOAF (GF*)

$29.00
Buttermilk Mashed Potatoes, Spring Vegetables, Mushroom & Herb Gravy, Grilled Farm Bread

WAGYU BOLOGNESE

$27.00
Kitchen Crafted Torchio Pasta, Parmigiano Reggiano, Garlic Bread

CRAB CAKE BENEDICT

$28.00
Cornbread, Hollandaise, Poached Egg, Breakfast Hash (ENTREE AFTER 3PM W/ ASPARAGUS)

STEAK FRITES*

$39.00
12 oz. NY Strip, House Steak Sauce, Fresh Cut Confit Fries ( ADD EGGS $5)

LIL BITES

(age 10 and under) *No substitutions or modifications

Meatball Bites & Fluffy Mashed Potatoes

$13.00

Crispy Chicken Tenders & Tater Wedges

$13.00

Toasty Grilled Cheese & Tater Wedges (V)

$13.00

SWEET TREATS

MUFFIN FLIGHT TRIO

$10.00
Strawberry, Blueberry, Chocolate Chip

VANILLA ICE CREAM (GF)

$6.00
Caramel Sauce

CHERRY JELL-O POKE CAKE

$10.00
Whipped Frosting

May 11, 2025

  • Order
  • Parties
  • Jobs