Carmella's Plates and Pints, Bar & Restaurant in Pittsburgh

About us

Where the whiskey selection meets New American fare

Built around upscale comfort food and a carefully stocked bar, this family-owned American restaurant in Pittsburgh reflects decades of hospitality experience from co-owners Carmella Salem and Michael Alberter. Carmella's Plates and Pints menu brings seasonal cooking, local ingredients, and a relaxed sense of polish to Pittsburgh. Exposed beams, stained glass, and an open fireplace shape the warm dining room. The kitchen balances creative plates with familiar appeal, while the whiskey bar brings together craft cocktails and extensive selections of bourbon, scotch, and tequila. Outdoor seating and a private party room add another way to settle into the experience.

Explore Our Menu

Comfort classics with a creative turn

The Carmella's Plates and Pints menu gives familiar dishes a more polished point of view. Wagyu Bolognese brings richness to the pasta lineup, while Bison Meatloaf offers a distinctive take on a classic. Kitchen Crafted Gnocchi and Mushroom Risotto round out a selection that also includes vegetarian choices, seasonal ideas, and homemade pasta. Join us and see why many see us as the best whiskey cocktail bar & restaurant in Pittsburgh.

Party at Carmella’s in Southside

Celebrate somewhere with character

An intimate private dining room gives special gatherings their own setting, with the fireplace and rustic surroundings adding character without taking over the occasion. Rehearsal dinners, engagement parties, bridal showers, baby showers, holiday parties, and b-day parties all find a natural fit here, backed by a welcoming atmosphere designed for time together.

See What's Happening

Good company sounds better with music

Live music adds another layer to Carmella's lively side, giving guests a reason to linger over dinner or drinks. Happy hour specials bring a more casual rhythm, while brunch pairs the kitchen's comfort-driven approach with mimosas and cocktails. With indoor warmth and outdoor seating, the setting of our SouthSide restaurant shifts easily with the occasion.

Reservations

Digital Passport Books

Sign up now for our new Digital Passport Books!

Choose your spirit: Bourbon, Scotch, or Tequila, and become a VIP Passport Member by completing your Passport Book and getting your name on Carmella’s Whiskey Wall of Fame!

Sign up now, you are leaving the website, opens in a new tab
previous slidenext slide

Newsletter